Home / Building Owners / Evaluating Your Manager

Building owner guide

How to Evaluate Your Property Manager

A quiet building is not always a well-managed one. Regular reviews against agreed measures can show you what is working, and they can reveal problems early.

Set the measures first

A fair evaluation needs a baseline. Agree on objectives at the start of the year, such as a budget, an occupancy goal, a maintenance plan and reporting dates. Then you can judge results against those commitments and avoid relying on general impressions.

Financial reporting

Start with the basics. Do the reports arrive on time? Do the numbers reconcile? Can your manager explain a variance without having to look it up? Pay attention to these indicators:

  • Actual results compared with budget, by line item
  • Rent collections and the age of unpaid balances
  • Timely, accurate reconciliations of tenant expense charges
  • Bank reconciliations completed monthly
  • Clear explanations of unusual items

Budget performance

A manager who hits the budget by delaying needed repairs has only moved the expense into a later year. When you review the numbers, look at deferred items as well as savings. A good budget process includes realistic assumptions and an early warning when something will run over.

Maintenance and response

Walk the property yourself at least once or twice a year, preferably with the manager. Check the condition of roofs, mechanical rooms, parking areas and common spaces. Then review the records:

  • Are preventive maintenance tasks completed on schedule?
  • How long do work orders stay open?
  • Do repeat problems point to a root cause that has not been fixed?
  • Are vendor insurance certificates current?

Tenant communication

Tenants experience the manager every day, so their view is useful evidence. With your manager’s knowledge, ask a few tenants how quickly requests are handled and whether they feel informed. Watch renewal rates and the reasons tenants give for leaving, while recognizing that market conditions also play a part.

Contract compliance

Once a year, read the agreement against what is actually happening. Check spending approvals, bidding requirements, insurance tracking and reporting deadlines. Small lapses can be simple oversights. A pattern of them is a warning sign.

Communication with you

You should hear about significant problems from your manager first, and promptly. Good managers bring options and a recommendation, along with the problem. If you often learn about issues from tenants or vendors, take that seriously.

The property manager performance review turns these questions into a form you can use at your annual meeting.

Questions

Common questions

A monthly look at reports and a formal annual review works well for many owners. Add a quarterly meeting if the building is large, the market is changing or a major project is underway.

Make the next decision with better information

Research management companies in your market, or browse more practical guides for commercial property owners.