Home / Building Owners / Changing Managers

Building owner guide

When Should You Change Property Managers?

Changing managers takes time and carries some risk, but staying with the wrong firm can cost more. Here is how to tell the difference and how to make a switch cleanly.

Warning signs worth taking seriously

  • Reports that are repeatedly late, incomplete or hard to reconcile
  • Unexplained charges, or vendors with undisclosed ties to the manager
  • Tenants who complain about slow or absent responses
  • Maintenance that is put off until it turns into an emergency
  • Frequent turnover among the people assigned to your building
  • You keep learning about problems from someone else
  • The firm no longer fits the property or your goals

Any issue involving missing funds or commingled accounts is in a different category. Contact your attorney right away.

Try to fix it first, when it makes sense

Some problems can be resolved. Put your concerns in writing, refer to the agreement and set a date for improvement. Ask whether a different property manager could be assigned, or whether the scope needs adjusting. If the firm responds well, you may avoid the cost of a transition. If nothing changes, you also have a clear record of what you asked for.

Read your agreement before you act

Check the notice period, termination fees, any tail commissions and the duties for turning over records. Ask your attorney whether you can terminate for cause or need to use the without-cause provision. Timing matters as well. Where possible, avoid a change during expense reconciliations, budget season or a major project.

Line up the replacement

Run the selection process before you give notice whenever you can, using the steps in our guide to choosing a management company. Tell candidates why you are making a change, and ask them to walk you through a recent takeover. Sign the new agreement with a start date that matches the end of the notice period.

Plan the handover

  1. Give written notice according to the agreement.
  2. Request a complete list of records and a delivery date.
  3. Confirm how bank accounts, security deposits and prepaid items will move.
  4. Collect keys, access codes and system logins.
  5. Transfer or reissue vendor contracts and insurance certificates.
  6. Notify tenants with the new contact details and where to send rent.
  7. Update insurers, lenders and utility accounts.
  8. Obtain a final accounting and reconcile it with your own records.

Our transition checklist breaks this into a working list you can assign.

Keep tenants confident

Tenants mainly want to know who to call, where to pay and that their service will not suffer. Send a brief letter with those details before the change takes effect, and have the new manager introduce themselves in person when possible. Then keep an eye on open work orders during the first month, because this is when requests are most likely to slip through.

Questions

Common questions

Often yes, but the terms depend on your agreement. Many contracts allow termination with notice, sometimes with a fee. Review the termination section with your attorney before acting.

Make the next decision with better information

Research management companies in your market, or browse more practical guides for commercial property owners.