Home / Tools & Checklists / Comparison Checklist

Tool

Property Management Company Comparison Checklist

Score each firm from 1 to 5 on the same points. Print one copy for each candidate, then compare the totals and your notes.

Experience and fit

  • Manages our property type today
  • Manages buildings of similar size and age
  • Active in our market, with nearby staff and vendors
  • Offers references from similar owners
  • Understands our goals: hold, reposition or sell

The assigned team

  • We have met the actual property manager
  • Their current workload is clear
  • A backup contact is named
  • Licenses and permits are confirmed with the state, where required
  • After-hours emergency process is explained

Financial management

  • Sample owner report provided
  • Reporting delivery date is stated
  • Budget process is clear
  • Accounts and security deposits are properly separated
  • Experience with our lease types and expense reconciliations

Maintenance and vendors

  • Preventive maintenance program is described
  • Work order tracking is shown
  • Bidding rules and spending limits are stated
  • Vendor insurance is tracked
  • Affiliated vendors and any rebates are disclosed

Fees and agreement

  • Base fee and what it is calculated on are clear
  • All other charges are listed
  • Spending authority fits our comfort level
  • Notice period and termination costs are acceptable
  • Agreement says the owner owns all records
  • Our attorney has reviewed the draft

Reference checks

  • Spoke with at least two owners of similar buildings
  • Asked about budget accuracy and report timeliness
  • Asked about the worst problem and how it was handled
  • Asked about unexpected charges

Comparing managers?

Research companies by market and property type, then compare them on the same criteria.

Make the next decision with better information

Research management companies in your market, or browse more practical guides for commercial property owners.