Home / Building Owners / Choosing a Company

Building owner guide

How to Choose a Commercial Property Management Company

The right firm depends on your building, your goals and how involved you want to be. A clear process makes the differences between firms much easier to see.

Start by defining what you need

Before you call anyone, write one page describing the property and your goals. Include the property type, size, tenant mix, lease structure, age of the major systems and any known problems. Then state what success looks like over the next three years. An owner preparing to sell needs something different from an owner planning to hold for two decades.

Decide which duties you want to keep. Some owners hand over everything. Others keep leasing with a separate broker, or keep final approval over vendors. A firm cannot price or staff the job accurately until it knows where its responsibility ends.

Build a shortlist of relevant firms

Look for firms that already manage your property type in your market. A company with deep experience in suburban office may have little practical knowledge of a multi-tenant industrial park or a medical office building with specialized systems.

Three to five candidates is usually enough. Sources include our company directory, other owners, your lender, your insurance broker and commercial real estate attorneys.

Ask for proposals you can compare

Send every firm the same information and request the same format. Ask each one to cover:

  • The team assigned to your building, by name, and how many properties each person handles
  • Current buildings of similar type and size in your area
  • Every fee, including what triggers leasing, construction and administrative charges
  • A sample monthly owner report
  • A plan for the first 90 days
  • How after-hours emergencies are received and escalated

Our comparison checklist gives you one scoring sheet to use across all candidates.

Check the qualifications that apply

Many states require a real estate license or a specific property management permit to collect rent or lease space for others, but the rules differ. Ask which licenses the company and its people hold, then confirm them with the state regulator. Also request proof of general liability, professional liability and crime or fidelity coverage.

Industry credentials can be a useful signal of training. Treat them as one input rather than proof of how well a firm will run your building.

Interview the people who will do the work

The senior person who presents the proposal may not be the one answering your calls. Meet the assigned property manager and ask how they would handle a real situation from your building, such as a roof leak on a holiday weekend or a tenant who has fallen behind on rent.

Call references with specific questions

Ask for references from owners of similar buildings, including one who has left the firm, if possible. Useful questions include:

  • How accurate were the budgets compared with actual results?
  • Did reports arrive on time, and did you need to chase anything?
  • How did the firm handle the worst problem you had?
  • Were there charges you did not expect?
  • Would you hire them again for the same building?

Review the agreement before you commit

The proposal describes intentions, but the contract sets the obligations. Read our guide to management agreements and have your attorney review the final draft, paying close attention to spending authority, ownership of records and termination rights.

Comparing managers?

Research companies by market and property type, then compare them on the same criteria.

Questions

Common questions

Timing varies with the size of the building and the number of candidates. Allow enough time for proposals, interviews, reference calls and legal review so that you are not forced into a rushed decision by a contract end date.

Not on fee alone. Compare the total cost and what is included. A lower percentage can cost more once separate charges are added, and weak oversight can cost far more than the difference in fee.

Make the next decision with better information

Research management companies in your market, or browse more practical guides for commercial property owners.